Black Widow Theory: Yelena Died In Endgame, NOT Natasha
Although Black Widow will fill in a few of the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s story gaps, it’s not out of the realm of risk that Natasha Romanoff (Scarlett Johansson) lives on and her “sister” Yelena Belova (Florence Pugh) might have really been the one to make the sacrifice play in Avengers: Endgame. Black Widow will cowl the time between Captain America: Civil Struggle and Avengers: Infinity Struggle. This time span might maintain the important thing to the return of Black Widow to the franchise, regardless of her demise. It hinges on the query of whether or not or not Yelena, as Natasha, took the autumn in Endgame.
The announcement of the Black Widow movie was lengthy overdue, 10 years after the character’s franchise debut in Iron Man 2. Though, followers have been confused about its announcement following her demise within the fourth Avengers movie, it has since been revealed that Black Widow might be a prequel. It should observe Natasha’s journey again to Russia the place her story started, reuniting with faces from her previous, who’ve been described as her actual first household. Amongst them might be her surrogate sister, Yelena Belova.
Proceed scrolling to maintain studyingClick on the button under to start out this text in fast view.
Associated: Black Widow Concept: [SPOILER] Is The Secret Villain
Yelena and Nat went by way of the mysterious Pink Room collectively, receiving related coaching and being fed related Russian propaganda. They’re close to equals, understanding one another inside and outside. This makes them two of many Black Widows. Due to this, one might convincingly imitate the opposite, and it has been theorized that in some way Yelena was the one who lived by way of the occasions of Infinity Struggle and Endgame disguised as Nat. This is able to recommend that Black Widow continues to be alive chronologically.
COPYRIGHT_BP: Published on https://bingepost.com/black-widow-theory-yelena-died-in-endgame-not-natasha/62740/ by - on 2020-03-16T02:13:48.000Z
In some unspecified time in the future in Black Widow, Yelena might “borrow” Natasha’s face, and know-how launched in Captain America: The Winter Soldier makes this a risk. The Photostatic Veil is a chunk of S.H.I.E.L.D. espionage gear. When positioned over the face of the person, s/he takes on the looks of another person. Natasha used it within the 2014 movie to thwart Hydra’s takeover of S.H.I.E.L.D. masquerading as World Safety Council member Hawley (Jenny Agutter). It additionally noticed a handful of makes use of within the Brokers of S.H.I.E.L.D tv sequence.
It’s unknown as of now whether or not or not Photostatic Veils might be in Black Widow. In that case, sooner or later within the movie Yelena might convincingly replicate Nat’s face seemingly for the sake of their mission towards the enigmatic Taskmaster. There could possibly be some sort of mix-up that ends in the 2 buying and selling locations from that time on.
If that is so, there are wider implications on the MCU that must be addressed. For one, the timing of their change could be a key piece of knowledge. Did it happen after Civil Struggle? After Infinity Struggle? Another time? How lengthy was Yelena assuming Nat’s life? The reply would create a domino impact of different questions. The end result of these questions would have an effect on Natasha’s largest second within the franchise: her demise in Endgame and the repercussions of her sacrifice for the Soul Stone.
Associated: Avengers: Endgame Deleted Scene Reveals Alternate Black Widow Dying (& It is Worse)
On the brilliant facet, Black Widow would nonetheless be alive, and Scarlett Johansson might doubtlessly return to the character in future MCU movies. Nonetheless, the emotional resonance of her demise could be largely misplaced. Her demise in Endgame altered your complete story. The unique Avengers have been in shambles. This is not to say Yelena’s demise would not be unhappy, nevertheless it means Natasha’s selection could be in the end cheapened, regardless as to how unusually it got here off. A bait-and-switch would tarnish the movie retroactively.
So far as story points go, there are lots to debate. Narratively, it’s extremely convoluted. For as detail-oriented because the MCU may be, that is nearly an excessive amount of. It might undercut Natasha’s story, coming off as a knee-jerk response to the fan outcry for her return. In doing so, it might additionally squander Yelena’s potential within the franchise, decreasing Florence Pugh’s half within the MCU to a mere physique double. Pugh has confirmed she is worthy of a lot extra with a affluent future within the franchise. A twist like this could throw all of that out for no good cause.
Logically, this concept is exasperating. Why would Yelena select to dwell Nat’s life for therefore lengthy? Higher but, the place is Natasha for this complete timeframe? Additionally, its extremely unlikely she might mimic Nat in each attainable manner from her actions to her speech patterns right down to the final microscopic element. Particularly troublesome are her recollections. Photostatic Veils solely work on the floor, not for character. After years aside, Nat could not have presumably instructed Yelena all the pieces about her post-Pink Room life so shortly.
Even when she did pull it off, Yelena would absolutely be came upon by her friends finally. It is a given she’d should take away the veil sooner or later. All it might take is for one individual to see her and the entire act could be up. Whether it is to be accepted that nobody observed, it’s an insult to the intelligence of her teammates. In that very same vein, it might be a serious insult to that of the viewers as effectively.
Associated: Black Widow Concept: All Of Natasha’s Household Are Killed By Thanos
Although it’s enjoyable to invest, it’s seemingly that Natasha and Yelena will hold their faces to themselves. Black Widow is a prequel, so in the interim she stays deceased chronologically. Black Widow will see the massive display screen another time although, and she or he is not the one hero to rise from the grave in Part 4, as Imaginative and prescient (Paul Bettany) and Gamora (Zoe Saldana) have been confirmed to look in future MCU movies. Nonetheless, till Black Widow hits theaters hypothesis can nonetheless run wild. May Yelena have taken Natasha’s face and her selfless second in Endgame?
Extra: Black Widow Concept: Natasha Is Finishing The Avengers’ Civil Struggle Mission
Key Launch Dates
- **Black Widow (2020)**Launch date: Could 01, 2020
- **Eternals (2020)**Launch date: Nov 06, 2020
- **Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings (2021)**Launch date: Feb 12, 2021
- **Physician Unusual within the Multiverse of Insanity (2021)**Launch date: Could 07, 2021
- **Spider-Man: Homecoming 3 (2021)**Launch date: Jul 16, 2021
- **Thor: Love and Thunder (2021)**Launch date: Nov 05, 2021
- **Black Panther 2 (2022)**Launch date: Could 06, 2022
Frozen 2: The Voice Elsa Hears Is Her Own (Explained)
About The Creator
Shane O’Neill is a author, moviegoer, health club addict and throughout nerd. From Marvel to Star Wars, he is by no means too busy to catch a film on opening evening. He’s at the moment attending the College At Buffalo for a Bachelors in Movie Research and has been finding out movie independently for years. For the previous yr he has reviewed movies as a interest and has been itching to share his ideas with the world.
Extra About Shane O’Neill