Historian William Mann On How The 1918 Spanish Flu Changed Hollywood Forever & How COVID-19 Might Too

The 12 months was 1918. As World Conflict I used to be ending, the Spanish Flu started ravaging the world. Inside a 12 months, it killed 675,000 People and 50 million worldwide — 10 million greater than those that perished within the conflict.

There are a number of parallels between the response to the Spanish Flu and COVID-19 within the U.S. In each instances, states of emergency have been declared; all public locations, together with film theaters and colleges, have been closed for months; and sporting face masks in public was really helpful.

The Spanish flu pandemic caused cataclysmic modifications within the movie enterprise, most of them orchestrated by Adolph Zukor. It led to the institution of the studio system, which continues to dominate Hollywood, and vertical integration, with studios wrestling management over film theaters from mom-and-pop house owners.

Associated Story

[

COPYRIGHT_BP: Published on https://bingepost.com/historian-william-mann-on-how-the-1918-spanish-flu-changed-hollywood-forever-how-covid-19-might-too/87812/ by Hilda Workman on 2020-04-07T00:27:41.000Z

Coronavirus: List Of Canceled Or Postponed Hollywood & Media Events

](https://deadline.com/2020/04/coronavirus-canceled-postponed-hollywood-sports-entertainment-1202870762/)

[

HarperCollins

](https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/tinseltown-book.jpg)

[

In an interview with Deadline, Hollywood historian William Mann, creator of Tinseltown: Homicide, Morphine, and Insanity on the Daybreak of Hollywood, which he and Kevin Murphy are adapting right into a sequence for Spectrum Originals, talks in regards to the Spanish flu pandemic’s profound affect on the movie enterprise, what massive shakeups the present pandemic might deliver (particularly in theater possession), and the way lengthy would it not take for Hollywood to recuperate. He additionally factors out errors made in dealing with the Spanish flu pandemic that in the present day’s authorities ought to be taught from, acknowledges the largest star Hollywood misplaced to the Spanish flu, and highlights celebrities’ angle to sporting masks in public again then.

You may as well comply with a timeline of the 1918 epidemic in Hollywood underneath the Q&A that illustrates a few of the factors Mann makes and paints an interesting image of how the California and LA authorities tackled the disaster — generally successful, someday stumbling — and the way theater house owners fought for survival.

DEADLINE: You could have studied each chapter of Hollywood’s historical past. Why is this era, from about 1918 via about 1926, so necessary?

MANN: That is when Hollywood is created, that is when the entire buildings that will outline the American movie business have been put into place — how motion pictures have been made, how they have been offered, how they have been proven.

That is the second in historical past the place the American movie business determined to go a specific approach. As much as that time there have been many various methods this might have gone, impartial movies, artists management — they tried that with United Artists. However the studio system was created on this interval and it actually begins with the 1918 epidemic.

DEADLINE: What position did the pandemic play within the creation of the studio system?

MANN: In the course of the outbreak, between 80% and 90% of American film theaters have been closed for wherever between two to 6 months. This was an enormous disruption and never solely moviegoing however movie-selling and moviemaking. It was patchwork throughout the nation. New York and San Francisco held out for the longest time however ultimately they needed to shutter as nicely.

Los Angeles put out a ban fairly early on theaters. The studios — and that is when studios have been each in Los Angeles and New York — put a ban on filming crowd scenes, and, to their credit score, studios shut down all manufacturing throughout this time period for nicely over a month, from the center of October to the tip of November of 1918.

First instances in L.A. have been introduced in September. About 3,000 folks died in Los Angeles in somewhat greater than a 12 months, 1 / 4 of all of the deaths from that interval. We neglect how vital an affect this has had, and loads of that was financial affect.

The studios had vital losses. Paramount misplaced practically $2 million in 1918 to 1919; that’s extra like $30 million now. Distributors additionally suffered as a result of you may’t ship movies when theaters are closed. However the higher financial affect was felt by the exhibitors, the mom-and-pop film theaters throughout the nation, which have been ruined by this. Loads of them have been dwelling month to month, displaying movies and struggling to pay their payments, and after they out of the blue have been pressured to shut for 2, three, 4, six, seven months, they misplaced all the things. Even after the theaters reopened, in lots of instances they didn’t come again till the center a part of 1919, so film theaters have been closing left and proper.

The truth was at this cut-off date that American movie exhibition was actually mother and pop. It was small city, it was impartial exhibitors. Some had fashioned a sequence, a few of them had fashioned associations, however for essentially the most half it was not an enormous management over the exhibition, and that’s the place Adolph Zukor is available in. As a result of he had this concept approach earlier than the epidemic that if I might get management of all of those theaters, then I might management all the business, so he makes use of the epidemic to place that plan into place.

DEADLINE: How did he try this?

](https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/tinseltown-book.jpg)

[

ZukorParamount/Kobal/Shutterstock

](https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/adolph-zukor.jpg)

[

MANN: Zukor is an interesting man. He’s a villain however he’s additionally a man with imaginative and prescient, and what he did put so many individuals out of enterprise however on the similar time created the American movie business, and it ran this manner for the following 60-70 years. In some methods Zukor’s imaginative and prescient of filmmaking continues to be used in the present day, even with new applied sciences; it’s the mannequin of vertical integration, which implies top-down management.

So Zukor mentioned, right here I’m making motion pictures, I ought to be capable of then management how they’re distributed after which how they’re proven. By doing that, by taking management of all of the elements of the movie business, Zukor squeezed out all of those impartial filmmakers, a lot of whom have been girls. He exploited the pandemic to construct his new mannequin during which girls are lower out from positions of energy, to not point out additionally folks of colour as a result of there was quite a few African-American and Chinese language-American and Mexican-American filmmakers who have been working in Los Angeles and had their very own firms, had their very own distribution networks. However when Zukor buys up all the things, so many individuals lose entry then and lose a voice within the business.

Zukor needed to do that all alongside however he noticed this was the golden alternative, and sends his legal professionals out all throughout the nation as a result of he says he’s getting all these reviews about theaters closing. He goes, “Oh, OK, so we simply exit and supply them to take it off their fingers.” And in the event that they weren’t keen to promote for pennies on the greenback, say, “Nicely, I’m going to construct one other theater throughout the road and put you out of enterprise.” They have been drained, they have been exhausted, they have been shedding cash, they usually simply threw within the towel and gave in.

By 1921, Zukor, who was the top of what was known as then Well-known Gamers that turns into Paramount, was the largest particular person within the business. He managed extra theaters, he managed extra movies, and he saved it that approach for fairly a very long time.

DEADLINE: Trying now at film theaters closing and what occurred in 1918, how will the theater house owners come out of the coronavirus pandemic on the opposite finish?

MANN: I feel it’s going to be actually attention-grabbing. I feel the COVID-19 closures might find yourself having as vital an affect on the flicks because the 1918-19 influenza did. It is going to be completely different in fact, however simply as in 1918 the entire construction of the business might change in a few years.

The cinema in 1921, simply two years after the epidemic, was nothing just like the business from 1918, it had so radically modified. The size of the flicks and the way in which folks purchased tickets for motion pictures, all of this modified.

I look now at streaming providers that now principally use Zukor’s mannequin. They management manufacturing, distribution and exhibition. Zukor could be cheering them on. And sure, it does get a few of the smaller folks out of enterprise, however there’s additionally … it’s a really environment friendly mannequin and possibly via this business’s going to seek out one other approach in ensuring that the product nonetheless will get on the market.

DEADLINE: As a substitute of predominantly mom-and-pop-owned theaters we have now primarily theater chains now. Will that think about to what occurs to them or will it’s simply greater gamers getting out of enterprise? Who do you suppose in a pair years will personal these theaters and can they continue to be related within the ear of streaming?

MANN: All people’s asking the query now, are we ever going to return to the film theaters? This has been virtually a few a long time now as motion pictures have turn into arduous to do for specific audiences, and smaller motion pictures have moved over to Netflix or to Amazon.

It’s arduous to say that, as a result of Zukor in 1918 noticed the issue and exploited it, each for his personal ends, however I additionally suppose for the nice of the American movie business. I feel that would occur right here now. I don’t know who owns these film theaters, will it’s streaming firms, will it’s any person else, studios? I don’t know, however clearly there’s going to be some form of a change.

DEADLINE: Another parallels between the COVID-19 and the Spanish flu pandemic? On a neighborhood authorities stage, the response is fairly related, via in 1918 it appeared extra chaotic, with a lockdown imposed, lifted after which enforced once more a number of instances. What’s completely different this time, particularly right here in California and Los Angeles?

MANN: Sure, you hit the nail on the top: Oftentimes these closings have been lifted in 1918 approach too quickly. Folks have been nonetheless dying of this in March and April and Might of 1918. Mary Pickford, who was the largest film star of the time, she will get it in early 1919, so the film theaters would reopen and no person would come after which they’d shut because the dying price continued to climb.

There must be a higher consistency — there may be understanding, hopefully, that we’ve discovered from 1918. You don’t try this, you retain the social distancing so long as you may. They didn’t use that phrase again then however I hope we discovered, don’t repeat these errors.

DEADLINE: One of many errors we seem to have repeated is to not have sufficient face masks.

MANN: Sure, one of many issues that was attention-grabbing to me as I used to be studying via this materials a number of years in the past after I was researching the ebook, however then once more extra lately when COVID hit, was the scarcity of masks. Folks didn’t have sufficient masks, after which when folks did get masks, it was seen as form of cowardly — you’re a weakling in the event you’re going to put on a masks. A few of the greatest Hollywood stars would intentionally not put on masks in public as a result of they didn’t wish to seem, particularly the boys, they needed to seem manly and masculine and you already know, to put on a masks it was going to indicate that he’s weak.

DEADLINE: What have been the very best recognized Hollywood victims of the 1918 pandemic? Lots of the greatest stars have been lucky and recovered.

](https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/adolph-zukor.jpg)

[

PickfordCommon Historical past Archive/UIG/Shutterstock

](https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/mary-pickford.jpg)

[

MANN: Sure, loads of them did recuperate. Mary Pickford recovered, Lillian Gish recovered. Each of them have been large, large stars. However the greatest title in Hollywood who died was an actor by the title of Harold Lockwood. No person remembers him in the present day sadly, however he was a very terrific actor. He labored for Metro which later turns into Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer and he was younger, I feel solely about 31 years outdated. Very good-looking, main man, and he will get sick and dies inside a couple of days. It’s surprising to the business, and the followers are devastated.

DEADLINE: We’re three weeks into the mass Hollywood shutdown. Studios are hoping to restart filming in the summertime. Primarily based on the occasions in 1918, when do you realistically suppose Hollywood will return to regular?

MANN: It’s so arduous to say. I imply, Hollywood in 1918 didn’t return to regular for actually for an additional 12 months. It took that lengthy to recoup their losses and to, you already know, get all the things reopened, so it took not less than a 12 months in 1918. We don’t actually see the film enterprise choose up once more, the stoop doesn’t finish till the tip of 1919, clearly into 1920. So it’s arduous to say how lengthy this one will take. I hope the measures we’ve taken now have been extra constant and hopefully it received’t take us that lengthy to recuperate from this, however clearly there’s going to be some financial ache all throughout the nation.

](https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/mary-pickford.jpg)

About The Authors

Hilda Workman - Hilda Workman is a licensed financial advisor with years of expertise in the industry. She has assisted a range of clients, from sole proprietors to large corporations, in reaching their financial objectives. She is informed about many different financial subjects, including tax preparation, investment planning and also in fashion. She believes that the best things are those that are imperfect.