Joel McHale’s Tiger King aftershow episode is a messy attempt at closure
Tiger King*,* Netflix’s stranger-than-fiction documentary, is a bona fide phenomenon. The seven-episode collection, at present topping Netflix’s high 10 most watched content material checklist, returned on Sunday with an eighth episode: an aftershow titled The Tiger King and I. Since Tiger Kinggrew to become an in a single day hit in the midst of COVID-19 social distancing, McHale carried out wrap-up interviews with the documentary’s topics from his sofa, over video chat. The result’s a messy try at closure for what was finally a really messy collection.
Tiger Kinghas been fairly criticizedfor specializing in Joe Unique’s outsized persona slightly than the actual victims of his poisonous persona, and The Tiger King and Iappears like a response to that criticism, shifting focus to the folks in Joe’s orbit who have been most affected by his actions. Neither Joe Unique nor his nemesis Carole Baskin have been interviewed for the aftershow, and fellow huge cat proprietor Doc Antle is likewise absent. Current as an alternative: Joe’s former workers Erik Cowie, Saff Saffery, and John Reinke; his marketing campaign supervisor, Joshua Dial; his ex-husband John Finlay; his webseries producer Rick Kirkham; and the brand new homeowners of his zoo, Jeff and Lauren Lowe. All of them share extra particulars about life with Joe Unique, and what got here after.
Because the interviewer, McHale valiantly makes an attempt to stroll a effective line between empathizing with the documentary’s topics, and joking in regards to the absurdity of their lives as portrayed in Tiger King. The shifting tone is a bit jarring, however the comic’s is simply so supernaturally charming that it’s not as off-putting because it may have been. McHale’s simple confidence additionally appears to assist the documentary’s much less flamboyant topics really feel snug opening up. Most of them didn’t count on the sort of celeb that being featured in the preferred documentary of all time (in accordance with McHale) would convey them. A number of interviewees comment that they’ll’t even make a fast Walmart run with out being stopped by a fan of the present. “They don’t care in regards to the COVID,” says former zoo supervisor John Reinke. “They wanna shake your hand.”
Walmart fame isn’t the one factor the Tiger Kingtopics agree on, although. Going by social-media reactions, almost everybody who watches Tiger Kingthinks Joe is a foul particular person, however it virtually appears like a passive acceptance. It’s as if his violent outbursts are simply one other bizarre aspect of his weird persona. However in accordance with those that labored with him, Joe Unique was even worse than the documentary let on.
In one of many aftershow’s most harrowing moments, former head zookeeper Erik Cowie shares that he was the one who needed to tranquilize tigers — a few of them wholesome younger adults — earlier than Joe euthanized them to make room for extra kittens. “These cats trusted me to the tip,” Cowie says. And Rick Kirkham, who lived on the zoo compound whereas filming a Joe Unique TV present, recollects that Joe as soon as promised a girl he’d soak up her ageing horse to let it reside out the remainder of its days on the zoo. As quickly as she left the car parking zone, nevertheless, Joe shot the horse and fed the meat to his tigers. (Kirkham additionally drops that Joe was truly afraid of his huge cats, and by no means received close to them until they have been tranquilized or in any other case impaired.)
It doesn’t seem that Joe was any kinder to his human associates. John Reinke remembers Joe continually saying that Reinke would by no means be capable to run the zoo on his personal. “He at all times tried to maintain everybody smaller than him,” says Reinke. Joshua Dial, who witnessed Joe’s husband, Travis Maldonado, by chance shoot himself within the head, was by no means given entry to mental-health assets, and remains to be saving cash for counseling. Erik Cowie was much more succinct, stating merely, “[Joe Exotic] was an asshole, man.”
One of many questions McHale asks virtually everybody (together with “Who ought to play you in a Tiger Kingadaptation?”) was whether or not Joe Unique ought to be in jail. The result’s a unanimous “Sure.” Saff Saffrey, nevertheless, is the one one who extends Joe any mercy. Saffrey has been hailed as the true hero of the show— his calm demeanor within the face of every little thing from being misgendered to shedding his arm in a tiger assault stands in stark distinction to Joe’s mania. Even whereas agreeing that justice was served, Saffrey doesn’t need Joe to die in jail. Citing the free Thanksgiving dinners that Joe provided his neighborhood, he says, “Joe did numerous messed-up stuff, and that’s a truth … however he did numerous good issues too.”
A number of the administrators’ selections within the authentic seven episodes of Tiger Kingreally feel a bit icky, like spending a whole episode constructing the case that Carole Baskin killed her husband and displaying the footage of Joshua Dial witnessing Travis Maldonado’s loss of life. However the aftershow gives a little bit of catharsis. It’s uncomfortable to be reminded in regards to the depths of Joe Unique’s cruelty, however it’s an essential reminder, particularly as Tiger Kingmemes flood social media. The memes gained’t cease, however it’s higher to let the folks whose lives Joe Unique affected most to have the final phrase. And it’s uplifting to see them apparently doing effectively after leaving Joe’s poisonous orbit, particularly his ex-husband John Finlay, who was disenchanted that the collection portrayed him as a drugged-out hillbilly. (In The Tiger King and I, he’s carrying a shirt and sporting new enamel, which stands in stark distinction to his shirtless, toothless interviews on the present.)
Identical to Tiger King, The Tiger King and Iis messy, and it by no means totally settles on a tone. But it surely rightfully shifts focus to the actual heroes of the story — the underpaid zookeepers who appear to be the one individuals who truly care in regards to the animals’ wellbeing. Tiger King’s legacy will doubtless be difficult. Like a lot of true crime and actuality tv, it’s undeniably compelling whereas additionally being fairly exploitative. The aftershow doesn’t curb these instincts, however with out Joe Unique and Carole Baskin taking over a lot house, the very last thing viewers are left with is a glimpse at their feud’s fallout.
Vox Media has affiliate partnerships. These don’t affect editorial content material, although Vox Media could earn commissions for merchandise bought by way of affiliate hyperlinks. For extra info, see ourethics coverage*.*